Not All Dermal Fillers Are Created Equal: Selecting Treatment Based on Individual Patient Needs

Course Director

Julius Warren Few, Jr., MD

Julius Warren Few, Jr., MD
Director, The Few Institute for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery
Clinical Associate, University of Chicago
Chicago, Illinois


CME Credit
After reviewing the content below,
click here for a free, instant CME certificate.


Dr. Julius Warren Few, Jr. provides expert feedback to the questions submitted by your peers during a recent survey on this topic.

Overview

The use of injectable dermal filler agents has risen dramatically in recent years. Between 2000 and 2008, there was a 48% growth in nonsurgical treatments undertaken by American women, and 64% growth in men.1 A wide range of dermal filler products is available for these procedures, and hyaluronic acid (HA) dermal fillers are among the most commonly used. HA is a naturally occurring polysaccharide found in the extracellular matrix in many human tissues; approximately 50% of the total HA in the human body is found in the skin.2 When cross-linked, HA retains the natural characteristics that make it suitable for soft tissue augmentation but with increased durability.3 Optimal results require in-depth knowledge of facial aging and anatomy, as well as the individual properties and techniques specific to each product. It is imperative that treatment be tailored to the patient’s individual needs in order to achieve maximal benefit, minimize risk, and achieve the desired correction longevity.


What are the complications, common and uncommon, associated with using dermal fillers?

Answer: Complications are very rare with dermal fillers, but probably the most common complication is overfilling. There is a tendency to overfill, especially in the central face near the eyes. There are a few rare complications such as infection, particularly in darker skin. Herpetic infections can occur in patients who have a history of cold sores after an injection around the mouth or the lips. The most dreaded complication is intravascular injection of product, which can then cause embolization or occlusion of blood vessels, resulting in necrosis. This complication is fortunately very rare with hyaluronic acid fillers; in 8 years of using these agents I have only seen it in 2 or 3 patients. These patients had been treated outside of my practice. This complication can be avoided by not injecting under a lot of pressure and not overfilling in areas that could constrict blood vessels, such as the base of the nose. If overfilling does occur, we can prevent necrosis by using hyaluronidase to break down hyaluronic acid fillers. It takes about 24 hours for hyaluronidase to literally melt the filler.

Back to top

Apart from clinical judgment, what is the best way to individualize the degree of correction to a facial fold or wrinkle?

Answer: As a starting point, we can look at averages. Most patients will present with a class 2 or class 3 nasolabial fold and in those cases the average is between 2 and 3 syringes on both sides. But the answer to the question in practice is highly variable, depending on skin quality and elasticity. Patients with loose skin may require more product to get the desired effect, while those with rejuvenated skin or who have had a facelift may require less. Expertise and training with dermal fillers is critical in making these decisions.

We also need to factor in patient preference. Some patients will want the fold or the wrinkle to be completely erased, and others will want to have most of it erased or have some sign of the wrinkle or fold for a more natural effect. Again, I like to fill one side to what I think is ideal for that patient, and then have the patient evaluate. This approach accomplishes two things: 1) It allows the patients to have a real-life opportunity to assess the results; and 2) it also maps out how much product we will need to achieve the desired result. For example, if I use one syringe on one side, it's fair to say that I’ll use another syringe on the other side.

Good technique – not injecting under pressure, not trying to put too much product into a given area – is essential to ensure safety and to achieve optimal effects.4 Of course, good sterile technique is also key to avoiding complications.

Back to top

With all of the fillers available, how does one decide which filler to use? Please discuss locations and options for each, particularly with regard to duration of effect.

Answer: I look at the G prime (G’) of each product, which gives us insight on the turgor or stiffness of the given filler or the ability of the product to lift a given amount of weight (Table 1). All the available fillers have different lifting capacity.2 G’ is determined by HA concentration, particle size, degree of crosslinking, as well as the presence of uncrosslinked HA.

We can use the G’ factor to select the appropriate filler for the area being treated. For example, products with a higher G’ are not suited for shallow areas, since the product is likely to be palpable under the skin. I tend to only use product with high G’ deep in the cheek, almost like an implant. For areas with a deeper crease, like a heavy etched line on the forehead, or a deep nasolabial fold, I'll use the heavier G’ products. I would not try to use a product with a high G’ in a shallow area, such as the glabella. There are a lot of important blood vessels in that area that can lead to embolization.

Products with a medium G’ are my work horse. I have the most experience with these products, have done research with them, and find they are very versatile. All the fillers can work for nasolabial folds, but the differences show up when you start looking at superficial versus deep filling in other areas of the face.

Products with a low G’ are good options for lips, especially if a patient is looking for a soft enhancement. Typically I use lower G’ fillers for shallow wrinkles or folds, or a superficial area of treatment.

Table 1



Back to top

Please click here to redeem your CME credits now

References

  1. John HE, Price RD. Perspectives in the selection of hyaluronic acid fillers for facial wrinkles and aging skin. Patient Prefer Adherence. 2009;3:225-230.
  2. Tezel A, Fredrickson GH. The science of hyaluronic acid dermal fillers. J Cosmet Laser Ther. 2008;10:35-42.
  3. Beasley KL, Weiss MA, Weiss RA. Hyaluronic acid fillers: a comprehensive review. Facial Plast Surg. 2009;25:86-94.
  4. Dover JS, Rubin MG, Bhatia AC. Review of the efficacy, durability, and safety data of two nonanimal stabilized hyaluronic acid fillers from a prospective, randomized, comparative multicenter study. Dermatol Surg. 2009;35:322-331.

The materials presented here are used with the permission of the authors and/or other sources.
These materials do not necessarily reflect the views of Answers in CME or any of its supporters.

Medicis Pharmaceutical Corporation

This activity is supported by an educational grant from Medicis Pharmaceutical Corporation.

Privacy Policy || To receive e-mail updates, click here

Please contact info@answersincme.com with any questions, comments, or feedback about our programs.

About This Answers in CME Activity

Answers in CME, and the University of Florida College of Medicine are responsible for the selection of this report's topics, the preparation of editorial content, and the distribution of this report. The preparation of Answers in CME reports is supported by educational grants subject to written agreements that clearly stipulate and enforce the editorial independence of Answers in CME and the University of Florida College of Medicine. Our reports may contain references to unapproved products or uses of these products in certain jurisdictions. For approved prescribing information, please consult the manufacturer's product labeling. No endorsement of unapproved products or uses is made or implied by coverage of these products or uses in our reports. No responsibility is taken for errors or omissions in reports.

Hardware/Software Requirements:

Answers in CME requires minimum browser versions of: 6.x from Microsoft Explorer; 2.x from Mozilla Firefox; or 3.x from Safari.
Certain activities may require additional software to view. That software may be: Adobe Reader®